A cap on operating expenses is one of the most valuable protections a tenant can negotiate in a commercial lease, and one of the most frequently left on the table. At National Lease Advisors, we’ve helped clients recover millions of dollars by challenging landlords who didn’t apply their caps correctly.
We also see a clear pattern across our client base. Some tenants seem to get caps on nearly every lease, while others rarely have them. The difference usually comes down to how much priority the cap gets during negotiations.
What an Operating Expense Cap Does
An OpEx cap limits how much the tenant’s share of operating expenses can increase each year, typically to a fixed percentage such as 4% to 6% over the prior year or the base year. A few details determine how much protection the cap actually provides:
1. Controllable vs. all expenses. Most caps apply only to controllable expenses, excluding items like real estate taxes, insurance, and utilities. The definition of “controllable” matters, so read it closely.
2. Cumulative vs. non-cumulative. A cumulative cap lets the landlord bank unused increases from low years and apply them later. A non-cumulative cap resets every year and is far more protective for the tenant.
3. Base year vs. year-over-year. Whether the cap is measured against the base year or the prior year changes the math, especially after a year with unusually high or low expenses.
Two leases can both say “5% cap” and produce very different results depending on these terms.
Why It Costs a Well-Run Landlord Nothing
I started my career on the landlord side, and I never had a problem giving tenants a reasonable cap. Our property management teams budgeted reasonable annual increases and worked hard to make sure expenses came in on budget. If expenses grow at a normal pace, a cap set above that pace never comes into play.
That’s the point worth keeping in mind at the negotiating table. For a landlord who manages the property well, a reasonable cap is a concession that costs them nothing. It simply puts in writing what a good operator is already doing.
When the Cap Earns Its Keep
The protection really matters when owners and property managers don’t manage expenses well. Poor vendor oversight, deferred maintenance that turns into emergency repairs, or a change in ownership or management can all push costs up quickly.
It also matters when a landlord tries to push a major expense through operating expenses in a single year, knowing tenants have no choice but to pay. Without a cap, the tenant absorbs the full spike. With one, the increase is limited and the landlord carries the cost of its own decisions.
Why Some Tenants Get Caps and Others Don’t
Tenants who consistently get caps usually have a tenant rep broker who makes it a standard part of every deal. The best brokers we work with ask for it early and keep it on the table. When a cap is missing, it’s often because it was traded for other priorities like rent or TI allowance, or set aside after the landlord’s first pushback.
If you’re a tenant, let your broker know a cap matters to you. A good broker will make it a priority and push for it through every round.
How to Negotiate It
Our advice is simple: ask for a cap on every transaction. Expect it to be rejected in the first round of negotiations. That’s normal, and it shouldn’t end the conversation.
Keep bringing it back. When a tenant raises the cap in each round, most landlords eventually concede because they understand how important it is to the tenant, and because a reasonable cap costs them little if they run the building well.
Deal size does affect leverage. A 20,000 SF tenant will generally have more success than a 2,000 SF tenant. But we’ve seen tenants of all sizes with this protection in their leases, so smaller tenants shouldn’t assume it’s out of reach.
Getting the Cap Is Only Half the Battle
A cap only protects you if it’s applied correctly. Landlords and their billing teams frequently miss caps, apply them to the wrong expense categories, or calculate them against the wrong base. Unless someone reviews each year’s reconciliation against the lease language, those overcharges go unnoticed.
That’s where NLA comes in. Our team reviews annual CAM and operating expense reconciliations against each lease’s cap provisions, and when the landlord gets it wrong, we challenge the charges and recover the overpayment. Those recoveries have added up to millions of dollars for our clients.
If you’d like us to take a look at your leases, or to see whether your reconciliations are honoring the caps you negotiated, reach out to us at nationalleaseadvisors.com.